Skip to main content
Skip to store items
Skip to main navigation


Willy Street Co-op would love to cater your next gathering!

We offer fresh, made from scratch food with an emphasis on local, organic (in season) produce and locally produced dairy items. A general list of these local items can be found here. We have many healthy, high-quality options for any size event. If you want to keep your gathering fresh, green and local, choose us to help make your day special.

Pickup is available at both retail locations between the hours of 9am and 9pm (may differ for major holidays). Pickups are made at the Customer Service desk at either retail location.

Deliveries available by arrangement with our Catering Coordinator, for orders over $100.00. Delivery requests for orders under $100.00 may incur additional delivery charges. Please contact us to determine availability and options for this service.

Delivery Charges:
Residential:  $14.99
Business/School: $19.99

Catering Coordinator: Bill Pohlman
(608) 237-1201

Orders must be made at least 48 hours in advance.  Email and voicemail coverage is limited on Saturday and Sunday and ends at noon—please be sure to place your order by or before that time on Saturday and Sunday to ensure that we can fill it.  The Catering Coordinator must approve last-minute changes to service terms or agreements.

Willy Street Co-op Local Cheese Platter

Work or volunteer at a nonprofit that focuses on food, agriculture, environmental issues or cooperatives?

To say “thank you” for what these groups do for our business and community, we are offering nonprofit organizations in these fields a 20% discount on catering food orders. Does not include delivery charges. All catering service restrictions apply.

In an ongoing effort to maximize our purchases of Wisconsin-grown produce for our deli products and ensure the fairest prices for our customers, the Willy Street Co-op Kitchen has opened its procurement policy to allow for non-organic fresh produce only when Wisconsin-grown and only from farms that are known to us to practice agriculture responsibly.

We will always be able to cite the origin of any product that is not certified organic and will make a point of disclosing the names of our preferred farms as we weave them into our deli products.

Thank you! Not only did they bring the food to the car, but they helped when I had car trouble.


Absolutely phenomenal carrot cake!


Your cakes are delicious; it's difficult to get cakes made with REAL ingredients- Thanks


It is always very pleasing and friendly - Most know my name - It's been a very very pleasing and 1st rate service.


The vegetable platter received rave reviews for presentation, quality and the superb taste that comes with high quality produce. Everyone I spoke to wanted to know where the great veggie platter came from! Your veggie platter is far superior to the competition! Last but not least, the ordering process was customer friendly and convenient - one call and I received a great result! Thank you!


I was really happy that Thane was so receptive of my need to have a vegan and gluten-free cake.


The customer service was truly wonderful with prompt responses and flexibility for my custom order.


Staff was very helpful and the order was ready when we arrived. Thanks!


It was a delicious carrot cake for my daughters 1st birthday.


Worked out perfectly for an event that we weren't sure how many to expect.


I love the peanut granola bites and they are very well received. It would be great if you offer them routinely.


Guests commented on how good the cupcakes were. Great flavor consistency, everything. Thane was great about accommodating my request for smaller size for kids and pink frosting for my daughter's birthday.


Willy Street Co-op bakery is delicious and I know it's made with the best ingredients. Thane is great to work with and is super accommodating to our group and early morning needs.

Greater Madison Chamber of Commerce

Your cakes are AMAZING!

Marc K

Great food! Great people!

Madison Christian Community

Everyone was very helpful and accommodating. Thanks!

Christyn S