Main Menu

Everyone Welcome - Open 7:30am - 9:30pm daily

New Sandwiches

This spring the Willy East Deli has made some delightful changes to our sandwich menus. With the arrival of our new and efficient conveyor oven, we have the opportunity to offer our Owners and customers a new selection of “hot-off-the-belt” sandwiches and pizza slices. We now have daily offerings of gourmet vegetarian and vegan or meat pizzas of the day sold from our Deli case by the pound. We would love to heat it up for you on our new conveyor oven! Please remember that with any hot sandwich or pizza order to allow at least five to ten minutes for your order to be ready. If you have any additional shopping to do we would be happy to page when your order is done. We have also improved the “Fill-in-the-Blank” sandwich selections and added a kids’ menu.

Willy East Sandwich menu

Cate’s Roast Beef Hoagie $6.99
Local grass-fed beef from Cate’s Family Farm, roasted in-house. Served on a Tribeca Ovens rustic roll and topped with giardiniera and our house-made horseradish sauce.

Eberly Turkey Melt $6.99
Organic free-range turkey, roasted in-house. Topped with local Gouda cheese from Saxon Creamery, melted to perfection and finished with a drizzle of Drew’s Tangy Raspberry Vinaigrette. Heated and served on a Tribeca Ovens rustic roll.

Willow Creek Ham and Gouda $6.49
Willow Creek pasture-raised ham and local gouda cheese from Saxon Creamery, melted and topped with a hint of our house-made honey mustard sauce! Served on a Tribeca Ovens rustic roll.

Willy Street Rueben $6.99
Our original sauerkraut, local and rBGH-free Swiss cheese from Cedar Grove, Thumann’s all natural corned beef and our own chipotle mayo, served on Rudi’s organic rye bread. Heated to perfection!
*Also offered as a vegetarian option using our house-made marinated baked tofu!

Tuna Melt $5.99
House-made tuna salad served open-faced on a Tribeca Ovens rustic roll with tomato and local rBGH-free Swiss cheese from Cedar Grove.

Portabella Wrap (vegan) $8.29
Roasted portabella mushrooms marinated in a balsamic vinaigrette, our own vegan sun dried tomato pesto, and roasted red peppers, wrapped in a Indian Life tortilla.

Some other changes we have made to the sandwich menu this spring include giving the “Fill-in-the-Blankwich” a makeover. We have made it even more all-encompassing by including things like falafel and additional sauces and spreads to choose from. We are also implementing a ticket order system for customers to fill out when they would like to build their own sandwich.

Kids’ Menu
For the kiddos we have created a list of child-approved sandwich selections that can make any shopping experience with a hungry child pleasant:

Grilled Cheese Sandwich $2.69
Your choice of local, sliced cheese on your choice of bread with organically grown tomatoes.

Curious George $1.99
East Winds organic peanut butter, organic fair trade bananas and locally produced Gentle Breeze honey on your choice of bread.

Classic Peanut Butter and Jelly $2.49
Smooth organic East Winds peanut butter and organic grape jelly on your choice of bread.

Hummus Wrap $2.99
Willy Street original hummus and organic spring mix wrapped up in an Indian Life tortilla.

Willy West also has an amazing sandwich menu. Here it is:

Burger $6.99
Choose from a grass-fed burger, a prime rib burger, a turkey burger or a vegetarian Florentine burger, served on a Clasen’s roll with lettuce and tomato. Add two slices of cheese for $1.00.

Renee’s Chicken or Tofu Fajita Wrap $6.99
Marinated chicken breast or tofu, served with onion, roasted red and green peppers, salsa de cilantro, organic sour cream and shredded cheddar in a flour tortilla.

Willy Street Lamb Gyros $6.79
Thinly sliced house-made gyros meat, julienned onions, diced tomatoes, fresh parsley, our house-made tzatziki sauce, served on a warm Nature’s Bakery pita.

Grilled Cheese & Short Rib Sandwich $7.99
Shredded short rib, Cedar Grove provolone, pickled caramelized onions and fresh arugula served on sourdough.

Tofu Sandwich $5.99
Marinated Baked, Sesame, or Southern Fried Tofu served hot off the grill on your choice of bread with lettuce and tomato.

Pork or Tofu Cuban Sandwich $6.49
Shredded Willow Creek pork shoulder or tofu topped with Cedar Grove Swiss cheese and chili lime mayonnaise served on a pretzel roll and grilled to perfection.

Grilled Dairyland Cheese $3.99
Your choice of bread and and two of the following cheeses: cheddar, swiss, pepper jack, provolone, or Daiya vegan cheese.

Willy Street Reuben $6.99
Thumann’s corned beef, Cedar Grove swiss, sauerkraut and chipotle mayonnaise on caraway rye.

Sumi Shiitake Wrap $6.49
Sauteed, seasoned shiitake mushrooms and Sumi salad on a flour tortilla. Served with a side of our Pineapple Teriyaki sauce. Add Sesame Tofu for $1.50.

McKinley’s Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich $5.99
Marinated artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, baby spinach leaves on nine grain bread with a splash of red wine vinaigrette.

BLAST (Our version of a club sandwich) $7.99
Thumann’s oven-roasted turkey, Willow Creek bacon, lettuce, avocado, sprouts, tomato, and chipotle mayonnaise triple-layered on three slices of house sourdough.

Cate’s Roast Beef & Cheddar $6.79
Cate’s Family Farm’s beef, roasted in-house, served on a hero roll and topped with Cedar Grove cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and horseradish sauce.

Grilled Chicken or Tofu & Veggie Sandwich $6.79
Sliced grilled Bell & Evans white meat chicken or tofu served on your choice of bread, topped with roasted red peppers, sauteed red onions and squash, sprouts, lettuce, tomato, and tarragon mayonnaise.

Muffuletta $7.49
Crusty baguette stuffed with black forest ham, genoa salami, Black Earth pastrami, Cedar Grove swiss, provolone, and house-made olive salad.

Curious PB & J $2.49
Your choice of bread with peanut butter or almond butter, and any of the following: grape jelly, strawberry jelly, honey, or banana.

Make your own sandwich $6.99
Choose from the following breads: Baguette, Caraway Rye, Nine-Grain, Sourdough, Whole Wheat, Tortilla, Pita ($1.00 extra), or Gluten-Free!

Choose from the following meats (3 oz): Bacon (three slices), Cate’s Grass-Fed Roast Beef, Corned Beef, Genoa Salami, Black Forest Ham, Willow Creek Ham, Pastrami, Organic Turkey, Roasted Turkey, or Smoked Turkey.

Choose from the following fillings: BBQ Seitan, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Eggless Tofu Salad, or Chickpea Salad.

Choose a cheese: Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Provolone, or Swiss.

Choose a sauce: Chili Lime Mayo, Chipotle Mayo, Tarragon Mayo, Yellow Mustard, Dijon Mustard, Green Curry, Horseradish Sauce, Pineapple Teriyaki, Tzatziki, Or Tikka Masala.