Thanksgiving Offerings 2018


Turkey Options

All Thanksgiving turkeys will be available for pre-order Thursday, Nov. 1st through Thursday, Nov. 15th or while supplies last.
Please remember to specify the store at which you will pick up your turkey. Pick up between Friday, Nov. 16th and Thanksgiving Day (Thursday, Nov. 22nd) at 2:30pm.
We will have turkeys available as open stock starting on Friday, Nov. 16th. We cannot guarantee specific sizes or types of turkey without a pre-order. 

To pre-order: stop by or call customer service at any store. 

Bell & Evans
Organic Fresh Turkey
Fredericksburg, Pennsylvania
Fresh, organic free-grazing turkey, fed an organic meal.
Small: 10-14lbs. WILLY EAST SOLD OUT
Medium: 14lbs.-18lbs. - WILLY NORTH & WEST ARE SOLD OUT!
Large: 18lbs. and over - ALL STORES ARE SOLD OUT!
Ferndale Market
All-Natural Fresh Turkey
Cannon Falls, Minnesota
Fresh, all-natural free-range turkey, fed on a corn- and soybean-based meal.
Small: 10-14lbs.
Medium: 14lbs.-18lbs. Willy East is sold out!
Large: 18lbs. and over
Frozen All-Natural Turkey Breasts - $3.19/lb.
Ferndale Market
All-Natural Frozen Turkey
Cannon Falls, Minnesota
Frozen, all-natural free-range turkey, fed on a corn- and soybean-based meal.
Small: 10-14lbs.
Medium: 14lbs.-18lbs.
Large: 18lbs. and over

Meatless Options

Making vegan, vegetarian or gluten-free food for one or more guests? Check out our product substitution suggestions!

Field Roast Vegan Grain Meat Celebration Roast, 16 oz
On sale for $4.99
Save $2.00 11/14/18-12/4/18

Field Roast Hazelnut Cranberry En Croute Roast, 32 oz
on sale for $13.99
Save $3.50 11/14/18-12/4/18

Gardein Savory Stuffed Turk’y, 16 oz
On sale for $6.49
Save $2 10/31/18-12/4/18

Gardein Holiday Roast with Stuffing & Gravy, 40 oz.
on sale for $12.99
Save $5.00 10/31/18-12/4/18

Quorn Turk’y Roast, 16 oz
on sale for $5.99
Save $1.80 10/31/18-12/4/18
Available at North & West (not vegan)

Turtle Island Foods Tofurky Vegetarian Feast, 3.5 lb.
on sale for $21.99
Save $8.00 10/31/18-12/4/18

Turtle Island Foods Tofurky Vegetarian Roast, 26 oz.
on sale for $9.99
Save $3.50 10/31/18-12/4/18

Pie Options


Local Apple Pie
With apples grown at Sunrise Orchards in Gays Mills, WI.
Available as $18.99ea

Local Pumpkin Pie
With pumpkin & squash from New Traditions Farm in Hillsboro, WI.
Available as $18.99ea

Local Door County Cherry Pie
With Door County tart cherries.

Local Sweet Potato Pie
With sweet potatoes from various Wisconsin farms.

Pecan Pie
Made with US-grown pecans.

Willy Street Co-op’s Kitchen uses local eggs and butter, plus local produce when we are able. All pies use Wholly Wholesome crusts. Local Apple and local Pumpkin pies available as vegan/gluten-free.

Sample our Pies in the stores every Friday and Saturday through Thanksgiving!
Friday Samplings 4pm-7pm AND Saturday Samplings 11am-2pm

Holiday Deli Offerings:

The Deli hot bars at each of our stores will offer the following Thanksgiving foods Thursday, Nov. 15th through Thanksgiving Day (Thursday, Nov. 22nd) at 1:00pm:

  • Roasted Ferndale Turkey Breast (gluten-free)
  • Maple Roasted Root Vegetables (gluten-free)
  • Green Bean Casserole (vegan & gluten-free)
  • Traditional Gravy
  • Mushroom Gravy (vegan & gluten-free)
  • Sage Stuffing with Cranberries (vegan)
  • Garlic Mashed Potatoes (vegan)
  • Hazelnut Cranberry Field Roast En Croute (vegan)

Thanksgiving Catering

Why do all the work, when we can do it for you? Choose from any of our full meal options (traditional, vegan, and gluten-free), all made in our Co-op kitchen from high-quality ingredients. All include Ferndale turkey or Field Roast, gravy, five side dishes, dinner rolls, and pie.
Meal for up to 6 people - $89.99 
Meal for 6-12 people - $179.99 
Meal for 12-18 people - $269.99
Thanksgiving orders must be placed between Oct. 22nd and Nov. 16th. For details and to order, go to our Catering page.