By: Brendon Smith, Director of Communications
Y’all are a pretty steady bunch when it comes to your favorite Co-op-made products—the only change this year compared to last year was the Banana Bread Slice at #4 instead of the Vegan Chocolate Sheba Bar. Were you looking for a healthier treat? Did you make a New Year’s resolution to eat less chocolate?
There are a few changes here from last year! Yuppie Hill Eggs are #1, and we often hear that they have some of the deepest yellow yolks of any egg. (New Century Eggs ended as a company, or they likely still would’ve been in the top five.) Local orange sweet potatoes vaulted into second place, perhaps because of the increased interest in fiber and being such a nutrient-dense source of complex carbohydrates. Wisconsin Growers Co-op in Black River Falls has been supplying Willy Street Co-op with their local sweet potatoes for over a decade, and was the first local sweet potato supplier we worked with. The FEED Chocolate Chip Cookies 3 pack edged out last year’s #5 (Bunky’s Hummus), maybe because shoppers’ snacking interests have shifted from savory to sweet?
Lists based on sales of products 5/1/25-4/30/26. Does not include any products that have since been discontinued.
