Thanksgiving Pies 2026
Made locally by your Co-op’s Production Kitchen with thoughtfully sourced ingredients. Choose from apple, Door County cherry, pecan, pumpkin, and made-without-gluten vegan mini pies.
Made Locally by Your Co-op
Our Production Kitchen uses local flour, eggs, butter, apples, and cherries. Our pies are made with Fair Trade sugar.
Please note: Half pies will not be available. Made-without-gluten vegan pies are available only as 6-inch mini pies.
Weekly Pie Availability
- TuesdaysCherry, pumpkin, and made-without-gluten vegan apple
- WednesdaysApple, pecan, and made-without-gluten vegan pumpkin
- ThursdaysPumpkin
- FridaysCherry and made-without-gluten vegan apple
- SaturdaysApple, pecan, and made-without-gluten vegan pumpkin
Thanksgiving Week Availability
- MondayCherry, pumpkin, and made-without-gluten vegan apple
- TuesdayApple, pecan, and made-without-gluten vegan pumpkin
- WednesdayCherry and pumpkin
Pie Selection & Pricing
Willy Street Co-op
Apple Pie with Streusel
$9.99
$19.99
Made with local flour, butter, and apples, plus Fair Trade sugar.
Willy Street Co-op
Door County Cherry Pie
$9.99
$19.99
Made with local flour, butter, and cherries, plus Fair Trade sugar.
Willy Street Co-op
Pecan Pie
$9.99
$25.99
Made with local flour, butter, and eggs, plus Fair Trade sugar.
Willy Street Co-op
Pumpkin Pie
$9.99
$19.99
Made with local flour and butter, Illinois-grown pumpkin, and Fair Trade sugar.
Vegan · Made Without Gluten
Apple Mini Pie
$10.99
Made with local apples and Fair Trade sugar. Available only as a 6-inch mini pie.
Vegan · Made Without Gluten
Pumpkin Mini Pie
$10.99
Made with Illinois-grown pumpkin and Fair Trade sugar. Available only as a 6-inch mini pie.
Local
Grown or produced within 150 miles of the state capital or within the state of Wisconsin.
Vegan
Made without Gluten
